You can’t patent just an idea, supreme court rules again


The Air Force can now defend Earth without fear of trolls.

Doing the job that the patent office should have done in the first place, the U.S. supreme court stepped up to the plate and swatted down a long line of patent trolls. In an unanimous opinion issued today and written by justice Clarence Thomas, the court said that an Australian company, Alice Corporation, can’t take a common, centuries (millennia?) old financial practice – using a middleman to keep both parties honest – and claim a patent on it just because it’s being done on a computer…

There is no dispute that a computer is a tangible system…or that many computer-implemented claims are formally addressed to patent-eligible subject matter. But if that were the end of [it, a patent] applicant could claim any principle of the physical or social sciences by reciting a computer system configured to implement the relevant concept. Such a result would make the determination of patent eligibility “depend simply on the draftsman’s art,”… thereby eviscerating the rule that “‘[l]aws of nature, natural phenomena, and abstract ideas are not patentable’ ”.

Alice sued a foreign exchange company, CLS Corporation, because it had the obviously insane idea of doing its work on a computer without asking permission.

That’s the essence of what the worst patent trolls do: take a common idea or process, and use a computer to implement it. Then, they either find an existing patent that sorta talks about something similar or they submit an impressive looking but more or less impenetrable patent application and wait for the federal patent office to rubber stamp it. At that point, it’s a hunting license to prey on companies or, even, consumers who will pay a substantial but affordable sum upfront, fearing the expense of defending a law suit or the risk of losing.

The supreme court keeps kicking these shysters out the door, and we should be glad they do, but the real problem is congress won’t do anything to endanger the cash that the predatory bar showers on it and the patent office doesn’t have the smarts to know when it’s being snowed.

Posted in Uncategorized Tagged with: ,

Recent posts

At least it\'s moving again.\n\nCaltrans would have to let broadband companies and other organisations know about opportunities to include conduit in roa...
Oops.\n\nThe problems Frontier Communications had as it took over ownership and operating control of wireline phone systems belonging to Verizon were ch...
No mistaking when a copper head responds.\n\nAT&T isn\'t interested in third party improvements to the copper retirement bill it wrote and assemblyma...
Not everyone is 99 and 44/100% pure.\n\nNo one expected zero problems when Frontier took over Verizon\'s telephone systems in California last month. At l...
It\'s all Charter territory now.\n\nCharter Communications will own Time Warner cable systems in southern California and Bright House systems in the San ...
\n\nAT&T\'s attempt to force a bill through the California legislature that would allow it to, among other things, replace low priced, low margin wir...
Putting it in, or taking it out?\n\nRural counties in California are lining up against a plan to allow AT&T to replace rural and inner city wireline...
\n\nOpposition is growing to AT&T\'s attempt to rewrite California law so it can pull out its wireline networks in rural and inner city communities, ...
No landfall in Alta California so far.\n\nThere\'s opposition to Charter Communication\'s proposed takeover of Time Warner and Bright House cable systems ...
\n\nA plan to upgrade ancient, analog cable systems in the Salinas Valley and elsewhere in California to full digital capability could be on the Califor...

Activity

Tweets

Check you Internet Connection Speed

Speedtest.net Mini requires at least version 8 of Flash. Please update your client.